Sunday, February 12, 2023

"The Confession of Faith is not written in stone." Thoughts from a Jubilee Mennonite Church member about the upcoming vote to remove their church from the Mennonite Brethren conference

 

Elfrieda and Hardy Schroeder are members of Jubilee Mennonite Church. They came to the dual-conference congregation (both Mennonite Brethren and Mennonite Church Canada) from the Mennonite Brethren side of things.

 

For them, the ability to live together with differences is a hallmark of healthy Christian life. Now they lament being removed from the Mennonite Brethren conference over Jubilee’s decision to welcome and include LGBTQ+ people and affirm same-sex marriage.

 

Elfrieda provided a few thoughts for delegates to the March 3-4 assembly where they will vote on a resolution to remove Jubilee from membership.

 

Both my husband Hardy’s and my family were refugees after WWII. We both experienced homelessness and trauma at an early age. As children, we knew what it is like to be different and we haven’t forgotten.

 

In 1947, my family ended up in Paraguay where my father helped build the village of Einlage and became a pastor there. The school in the middle of the village turned into a house of worship on Sundays. Our village was made up of both Mennonite Brethren and General Conference Mennonites. They worshiped together. It was more important to talk about the things that united us than what separated us 

 

When I was nine years old, we emigrated to Canada. The small Albertan town in which we settled did not have a Mennonite church. We attended an Evangelical United Brethren church, founded originally by Pennsylvania Dutch Mennonites.

 

Our family was treated with love, kindness and respect. We did not have to change to belong there. Everyone was welcome!

 

My family eventually moved again and I was baptized at Springfield Heights Mennonite church by sprinkling. When I met Hardy, who was preparing to go to Congo with Mennonite Brethren Missions, Pastor Quiring of Brooklands Mennonite Brethren church, where Hardy was a founding member, asked if I would consider being rebaptized by immersion.

 

I declined, and the church voted to accept me. The mode of baptism had been an ongoing debate for at least 20 years in the Mennonite Brethren conference.)

 

When we returned from Congo, the debate among Mennonite Brethren was about women in ministry.

 

To those of us who worked long and hard with this issue, it was disappointing to have it defeated in the early 1990s. After 20 years, there is now no problem; it is left up to individual churches to decide.

 

In 2023, we at Jubilee Mennonite church are being denied membership in the Mennonite Brethren Conference because of our decision to fully accept LGBTQ+ in a committed relationship. 

 

Hardy and I were so happy when we moved to Winnipeg to discover a church that had membership in both conferences. Now this will be taken from us. 

 

The Confession of Faith is not written in stone. It will have changed twenty years from now. That will be too late for us.

 

Is there a pattern here? Please think about the significance of your decision!

 

Read an interview with Elfrieda and Hardy titled “I hope the MB conference would give us their blessing” from 2022.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Update on this blog: Time for a pause